Over a span of 5 years, two of Stacey Castor’s husbands died all of a sudden. While one was initially believed to be a pure demise, the authorities felt the opposite was a suicide. However, the investigation revealed one thing much more unsettling. The newest episode of ABC News’ ‘Fatal Flaw’ delves into the circumstances surrounding the 2 males’s deaths and how Stacey was suspected of killing them. So, if you happen to’re curious to seek out out extra, we’ve obtained you lined.
How Did Michael Wallace and David Castor Die?
Michael was a New York native born in September 1961. He was described because the lifetime of the occasion and had met Stacey in 1985. The couple had married in April 1990 and lived in Cayuga County, New York. They had two daughters, and all of it appeared high quality till January 11, 2000, when Michael was discovered unresponsive on the sofa; the 38-year-old was later pronounced useless on the hospital, and the docs believed he died of a coronary heart assault. However, an post-mortem just a few years later revealed the reason for demise as antifreeze poisoning.
Stacey married David Castor in August 2003, just a few years after Michael’s demise. They lived in Liverpool, New York, and David had a son from a earlier marriage. He was described as an outdoorsman and somebody who was work-driven. Sometime through the afternoon of August 22, 2005, Stacey referred to as 911 to report that she hadn’t seen David since he locked himself within the bed room the earlier morning. The 48-year-old was discovered by the authorities in his mattress bare, with a glass of antifreeze beside him. At the time, the police believed he had killed himself by ingesting antifreeze liquid.
Who Killed Michael Wallace and David Castor?
Michael started falling sick in direction of the top of 1999, and the household nervous about him. According to them, he had been performing unsteady. Michael’s sister additionally remembered him coughing rather a lot throughout a household dinner on Christmas Eve that 12 months. The docs had a tricky time determining what was incorrect with him and felt that he had an inside ear an infection.
However, simply weeks later, Michael was discovered useless. No post-mortem was carried out then, and his physique was buried quickly after. Then, Stacey married David Castor. She informed the authorities on the time of his demise that that they had an argument earlier, and David locked himself within the bed room and was consuming. On the day the physique was found, Stacey said that she tried reaching David a number of instances however couldn’t, ultimately calling the police. At that time, it appeared like suicide.
But what piqued the authorities’ curiosity was David’s will. He had left the whole lot to Stacey and her two daughters and nothing to his personal son. Furthermore, David’s ex-wife was adamant that he wouldn’t kill himself. At the crime scene, the authorities discovered Stacey’s fingerprints on the glass with antifreeze and positioned a turkey baster within the trash can with David’s DNA on it. They suspected that Stacey poisoned her husband and referred to as it a suicide.
So, the police continued engaged on it, and upon studying that Michael had additionally died, they determined to exhume the physique in 2007. An post-mortem confirmed that Michael had ingested antifreeze, with the investigators believing Stacey was liable for it. With the police closing in on Stacey, she devised one more sinister plan to shift the blame away from her. Shortly after Michael’s exhumation, Stacey poisoned her daughter, Ashley. The authorities believed that she typed up a suicide be aware to make it appear like Ashley was confessing to the murders.
Ashley, who survived, naturally denied the allegations, with the authorities arresting Stacey. While she maintained her innocence, she was convicted of killing David and trying to homicide Ashley, touchdown her in jail for a very long time. The prosecution additional believed that she cast David’s will so she would get the whole lot after his demise. Stacey died in 2016 whereas serving her time behind bars.