A younger mom was present in a St. Augustine, Florida, residence with a deadly gunshot wound. The authorities dominated it a suicide, however the investigation into Michelle O’Connell’s demise has been surrounded by controversy ever since. The circumstances and the way the inquiry was dealt with have been garnering nationwide consideration for the previous decade. Investigation Discovery’s ‘Citizen P.I.: Sleuths Under Fire’ chronicles how two personal residents began to look into Michelle’s demise. So, let’s discover out extra about this case then, lets?
How Did Michelle O’Connell Die?
Michelle was a 24-year-old single mom to a daughter, Alexis. She was described as a pushed girl who did every part to maintain her daughter. After working a number of jobs, Michelle had landed a full-time job at a daycare heart, and issues have been trying up for her. She had been in a relationship with Jeremy Banks, a sheriff’s deputy. On the evening of September 2, 2010, Jeremy made a disturbing 911 telephone name.
At round 11:25 PM, Jeremy known as in to say that he discovered Michelle on the ground and that she might need shot herself. Authorities rushed to his home solely to find Michelle mendacity face-up on the bed room ground. She had a gunshot wound to her face, and Jeremy’s service weapon was discovered on her left-hand facet. The authorities additionally discovered a second bullet within the carpet by her proper arm. The preliminary ruling by the medical expert was that it was a suicide. But after further data got here to mild, it was amended to being a murder, though it was by no means formally filed.
Who Killed Michelle O’Connell?
The investigators discovered that Michelle and Jeremy had gone to a live performance at an area amphitheater together with Michelle’s brother, Sean, and a few different mates. Jeremy was interviewed in a squad automobile after the incident, and in accordance with him, the couple had argued earlier than, throughout, and after the live performance. They had talked about breaking apart whereas on the best way again residence, and it appeared like Michelle had determined to finish issues and was packing issues to maneuver out.
Then, Jeremy claimed that he was exterior the home with some mates whereas Michelle stayed in. Once the chums left, he was contained in the storage when he heard a pop. By his account, Jeremy rushed inside to search out the bed room door locked, then heard a second gunshot. He mentioned that he kicked the door in to see Michelle on the ground with the wound. But sure inconsistencies have been recorded initially. Empty prescription tablet bottles in Jeremy’s title have been found in Michelle’s purse. The tablets have been positioned in Michelle’s pockets.
However, the toxicology report confirmed there have been no traces of the tablets in Michelle’s system. The younger mom’s household staunchly believed that Michelle couldn’t have killed herself. She had made plans to satisfy mates and was to take CPR lessons within the days after her demise. She was additionally excited concerning the new job. Instead, they believed that Jeremy shot Michelle to demise. There have been allegations made concerning verbal and bodily abuse within the relationship from each companions.
About 4 months after the demise, the Florida Department of Law Enforcement carried out an unbiased inquiry into the case. This time, the authorities discovered of two neighbors strolling exterior across the time of Michelle’s demise. They claimed to have heard arguing, after which a girl screaming for assist earlier than gunshots rang out. When proof was despatched by means of for testing, they discovered that there was no blood on the gun. Also, it didn’t have Jeremy’s DNA or fingerprints on it, which struck the authorities as uncommon.
Furthermore, Michelle’s DNA was not discovered on the tablet bottles in her purse both. There was some gunshot residue on Jeremy’s fingers, however the investigator felt that he might need washed his fingers earlier than the check, one thing Jeremy denied. A minimize over Michelle’s proper eye was deemed to have occurred earlier than the deadly gunshot wound and will have been attributable to the gun. The unbiased inquiry ended with the investigator believing Michelle’s demise to be a murder. This led the medical expert to amend the demise certificates, however he didn’t formally file it.
But regardless of the brand new findings, there have been no expenses filed in opposition to Jeremy as a result of the prosecutor believed there wasn’t sufficient proof. About 5 and a half years after Michelle’s demise, the household had an unbiased pathologist conduct an post-mortem on her physique. The physician noticed that Michelle had a fractured jawbone, which may have been attributable to blunt power earlier than she was shot. This was not talked about within the preliminary post-mortem report.
Where is Jeremy Banks Now?
After FDLE’s findings have been put ahead, Jeremy filed a lawsuit in opposition to the investigator, Rusty Rodgers, arguing that his civil rights have been violated. However, that go well with was dismissed by a federal decide, who dominated that Rusty had possible trigger to research whether or not Michelle was murdered. Earlier, Jeremy had additionally admitted to studying Michelle’s case file maintained by the sheriff’s division. However, Jeremy has maintained his innocence and has by no means been charged with any crime.
Recent reviews have indicated that he nonetheless works for the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office in Florida as a deputy. An inside investigation into Rusty’s work later revealed that he exaggerated sure data and excluded particulars. Two different health workers who regarded on the case additionally believed that Michelle had killed herself.
Read More: Where is Michelle O’Connell’s Daughter Now?